Showing posts with label Graphic Novel Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Graphic Novel Review. Show all posts

Friday, January 20, 2017

Graphic Novel Review: The Killing Joke

Batman: The Killing Joke is part of my DC Read-through, an ongoing series of posts inspired by a free eGalley I received. The eGalley was a magazine of the books DC claimed were the best places to start with their comics and I took this as a challenge. I handpicked about two dozen, and I try to read one or two a month. If you're interested in the rest of this series check out the tab above. My last post was a review of the first volume of Sandman and my next one is going to be V for Vendetta. Because this isn't a typical review I don't focus on the typical things, I stick mostly to looking at whether this is a good place to start with DC comics or not in lieu of plot details and my personal enjoyment.

This one is up there with Watchmen as one of the darkest comics I've ever read. Seeing as they're both written by Alan Moore I really shouldn't be surprised. I would argue, however, that this is darker, and perhaps, because it is shorter, it packs a very different, but still powerful, kind of punch to the gut than Watchmen did. Which is why I'm going to say that this is a poor place to start for any comic reader.

If you're looking to get into Batman comics this isn't the place. Sure, you're probably well versed in who the characters are, but if you want the full impact of the emotions that this is meant to convey I think you need to spend more time getting to know exactly who it is within these pages. I've read Batman comics before, but I still didn't get all the emotion that I think this is meant to convey. It's also not meant to be a set up for anyone really, but the Joker, as it does reveal a "version" of his backstory. While he may be one of the best character's ever written I don't think his is the head you want to enter into this series with.

If you're looking to get into superhero comics this also isn't the best place. The only hero to really appear is Batman and it's in a limited capacity. He's there, and his morals are certainly fleshed out nicely and quickly, but he himself isn't the most interesting part nor is he meant to be. It's not a comic about a hero as about the human condition, which it portrays beautifully.

Finally, if you're looking to get into comics in general I would say it's so-so. For a one-shot it's a really solid story, and if you're a connoisseur of fine things, particularly fine art, this is definitely a piece you need to add to your collection. However, if you're just generally looking to get into comics this will either be a turn on or a turn off. There's not really a middle ground with this one, so I would recommend starting somewhere else. If you're pretty sure this is the kind of things you want to read regularly, than by all means go for it, but if you're just kinda curious and not sure, try something else first to get a taste for the medium.

I do want to add a word on whether I liked it or not: I did but not really because of the plot (which I find a tad too disturbing for even my tastes) or the art (though it is very nice art that matches the story well) but because of how much of a statement piece it is as art and what it contributes to the genre. I like being able to see it on my shelf and I think it will be a nice piece for my collection for many years to come.

TL;DR? Perhaps not the best place to start with comics or graphic novels but definitely a must read if you think you can stomach it.

Monday, January 9, 2017

Mini Review: Showdown on Smuggler's Moon (Star Wars, Vol. 2)

After seeing Rogue One I wanted to keep the Star Wars bug biting so I picked up the second volume of the comic series. I read volume one several months ago and thought it fit the characters perfectly and did a nice job to fill in the space between the first two films. This one also does a very nice job of that, though I think it veered a bit further away from a plot I wanted than the first did. The characters are still spot on and I swear I can hear the actors voices when I turn the pages, and things jump off the page thanks to the great quality art.

For plot in general, it moved a little too fast for certain things to happen they way they did. In part of it Luke receives training, and I had a feeling, based off of what the characters said, that this lasted for at least a few days, or a week at most, but on the page that only amounted to one or two brief training scenes. Because of this I did get a bit confused over the timeline, which also makes it seem that everything that happens to Han and Leia takes place in about a day, while Luke's story clearly doesn't.

Everything paid off in the end, though, and I loved how it all finished out. Spoiler alert: seeing the original squad all holding Lightsabers was a dream come true.

Monday, January 2, 2017

Graphic Novel Review: Preludes and Nocturnes (Sandman, Vol. 1)

Welcome to the new year's first addition to my DC Graphic Novel Read-through. This is an ongoing series where I explore what DC has dubbed the best places to start with their comics. For that reason, these reviews focus less on the plot and development of the story and more on whether it's generally good and if you should start here. My previous posts in this story were for Watchmen and The Dark Knight Returns. This week I'm going in a different direction, and rather than picking up a superhero comic I went with Preludes and Nocturnes, the first collected installment of Neil Gaiman's The Sandman. My next review for this series will be for Batman: The Killing Joke so keep your eyes peeled for that one soon!

Going into this I'm more than a little biased since Neil Gaiman is my favorite author. In fact, it's rather surprising that it took me this long to even pick this series up! It certainly disappoint on the Gaiman front, and even though he claims it's not his finest work, his style seeks through the writing and translates incredibly well into a comic. The art was something I was worried about since it's far from conventional, but it really does work with this story and I can't even imagine anything different fitting onto the page quite as nicely.

I realize this is a hard book to sum up, probably because the plot isn't necessarily what makes it interesting. Basically: a group of magicians capture the otherworldly entity known as Dream (our "hero") which leads to his long imprisonment. After he breaks out he goes on a quest to reclaim what was taken from him.

If you're looking to go into comics but aren't interested in superhero's than I would certainly recommend this one. Especially if you're coming off books in the similar genre as this. It's a good graphic novel to cross over into the medium with, even though it is a bit unconventional. It's also a more mature graphic novel, though not necessarily because of violence of sex, more for the concepts and just the world within the pages itself.

However, if this is where you want to jump into classic DC fare don't start here. Sure, Constantine shows up, and there are passing references to some of the big hitters, but they're really just there to cement this in the world of DC not to really be a "part" of it. It's not a superhero comic, it's a fantasy/paranormal comic. 

TL;DR
Probably not the best place to start unless you're not interested in superhero comics at all. It is, however, one of the best graphic novels I've ever read so I can't recommend it strongly enough on that front.

Friday, August 5, 2016

Graphic Novel ARC Review: Awakening (Monstress, Vol. 1)


Author: Marjorie Liu
Artist: Sana Tekada
Edition: eGalley courtesy of Edelweiss
Release Date: July 19th, 2016
Rating: 3.5 Stars
I have been excited for this series ever since I saw the first issue released. I actually bought that first issue digitally, but I never got the chance to pounce on it, so I was even more excited when I saw this on Edelweiss.

I received Monstress Volume One from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.  Thank you!

Monstress is about a girl named Maika who has something she doesn't understand inside of her.  What she wants are answers- which means she has to get herself enslaved and into the middle of enemy territory.  Of course, she also needs to escape again...

When I started reading this I was swept off my feet!  The art is gorgeous (really, really wonderful stuff!) and the story starts by hurling you into a rich world with well defined characters and a unique story.  I was enchanted by everything, and even if I didn't know what half of it meant, I was enjoying the ride.

And then the ride got a tad too long.  The world is so full that every page had one new term or another, which is fine as long as there's something "normal" too touch base with, whether it's the art or another term that connects things.  Eventually there were small snippets that helped describe the world and the different races and the politics but for me they came too few too late and I was lost swimming in what felt like an ocean.  It really threw me off and made it hard to enjoy when I so confused for huge stretches of time.

Eventually I did figure it out (but it wasn't until the final two or three chapters) and I got back to enjoying the whole thing.  It really is an incredible story and, even better (at least for me) it focuses on female characters and depicts them super well!  As much as I love fantasy (and graphic novels) I have noticed how sometimes there just aren't enough women and while this has really been something that's been working on getting fixed lately (thank god for YA, which I credit for putting women back into literature and fantasy in particular) Monstress takes it into a whole other level.  Not only does it feature two pretty badass girls front and center but it's set in a matriarchal world which is such a great change.  Most of the characters, actually, are women and I love that so much!

This definitely isn't everyone's cup of tea but if you get the chance to pick it up I really do recommend it.  While it is confusing, I recommend skipping ahead (but don't worry, no spoilers) and checking out the pages that explain the world itself.  It will make the whole experience so much better and I promise you won't regret it!


Monday, July 4, 2016

5 Star ARC Graphic Novel Review: White Sand Volume 1


Author: Brandon Sanderson
Illustrators: Rik Hoskin and Julius M Gopez
Edition: eGalley courtesy of Netgalley
Release Date: June 28th, 2016
Rating: 5 Stars
I received an eGalley of White Sand in exchange for an honest review.  Thank you!

First of all, I'm a huge Brandon Sanderson fan.  I loved the Mistborn trilogy and Way of Kings.  I also own pretty much every other book he's written, even if I haven't read it yet, and most of them I got signed when I got the chance to go to a book signing two years ago.  But I still tried to approach this graphic novel from an unbiased place.

White Sand is billed as a missing piece of Sanderson's Cosmere (aka that grand plan he has for all his epic fantasy novels- go google it, it's awesome!) finally being released.  Sanderson himself said it works great as a graphic novel since the magic system is better seen than read and it also helped trim down the story.  It follows several characters, but most notably Kenton, a young, and rather talentless, sand mage who is trying to impress his father.  Tragedy strikes and sends him, and his world, into a tail spin.  He ends up traveling with a Duchess, Khrissella (better known as Khriss- and if you follow the Cosmere this probably means A LOT to you) from Darkside as she searches for answers.

Brandon Sanderson is the king of twists, at least for me.  I don't know how many times, when reading his books, where I just have to put it down and go "Did that really just happen?" in such a wonderful way.  Part of that is his fast-paced writing and exciting characters that don't give me the room to sit back and try to guess at what might happen, and part of it has to do with how good he is at timing and hiding things in plain sight.  Even knowing a little bit about what this was before starting, at the end of each chapter I ended up getting blown away and I couldn't stop reading.  The first chapter was a little rough for me, if only because I didn't care for any of the side characters and there were a lot of them, so it got a little distracting.  But then I read chapter two and I didn't put it down.

My favorite thing, beyond the amazing and unique magic system (do you expect anything else from Sanderson, though?) and crazy awesome world building (I really, really hope we get to explore this world more!), were the characters.  Kenton immediately draws the readers attention, but all the major players, revealed by the end of the book, are ones I'd love to read about even if it was just them.  Particularly Khriss.  I didn't know how I would feel about her when she was first introduced, but within two lines she has made herself a favorite of mine.

I can't wait to pick up a final copy of this one.  It's already released, so the only thing holding me back really is cost (and how much money I've been spending on books lately is getting ridiculous).  If you're a fan of Sanderson, or epic fantasy, or graphic novels, or just good stories, pick this one up!  The wait between them might kill you, but it will also give you the perfect opportunity to read the other books in the Cosmere (or reread them, whatever the case may be).


Thursday, June 16, 2016

ARC Graphic Novel Review: Klaw- The First Cycle


Author: Antoine Ozanam
Illustrator: Joel Jurion
Translator: Mike Kennedy
Edition: eGalley courtesy of Netgalley
Release Date: June 7th, 2016
Rating: 3 Stars
I received a copy of Klaw from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.  Thank you!

I picked this one up and nearly forgot about it!  It had caught my eye because of the concept, but I didn't really know what to expect.  After finishing it, I learned that the artist is praised for his style, and while I did think it was gorgeous art, the story is what I focused on when reading.

Klaw is about Angel, a young boy who comes from a wealthy family and is bullied at school.  He even has his own driver/bodyguard.  He has a massive crush on a girl, and when her boyfriend is killed, seemingly by a giant tiger, he begins to suspect himself.

This graphic novel is split into three parts, and each is totally different from the last.  While they all follow the same character, they seem to shift tones and genres.  The first one is somewhat of an origin/coming of age story, the second is a spy-thriller/climax of an origin, and the third is a superhero drama of sorts.

The first two parts of the graphic novel I was totally behind.  I enjoyed watching the character grow and mature and learn about what was happening to him and going on in general.  It's a lot for him to take in, but I think he does a good job of it.  Some parts of the pacing were rushed, but it felt fine in the context of the story.  There are some twists, too, that caught me off guard, and some that had me face palming when Angel didn't figure them out as quickly as I did.  It was the third part, though, that really rubbed me the wrong way.  Everything set up in the first two sections seem useless after several years of time jump.  The characters seem to go off character and all that maturing and growing that happened?  Where it went I don't know. Suddenly the pace was ridiculous and as a reader I felt like I had to play catchup because I had no idea what was motivating anyone anymore.  And that ending?  It didn't make any sense to me and has pushed me far from trying another volume any time in the future.

I don't mean to speak bad of it, because I was thoroughly enjoying the first two parts!  Never before has a fight between a Rooster and a Tiger been so interesting!  But the shift that happens in part three is ridiculous and almost seems like someone completely different wrote it.  I was glancing through reviews on Goodreads, to see if I was the only one who felt this way, and wasn't surprised when the vast majority of reviewers were also upset by the change.

If it sounds interesting, I recommend picking this up from your library.  Hopefully others will enjoy it much more than I did.

Monday, March 21, 2016

ARC Graphic Novel Review: Kicking and Screaming (Black Canary, Vol. 1)


Author: Brenden Fletcher
Artist: Annie Wu
Edition: eGalley courtesy of Netgalley
Release Date: March 2nd, 2016
Rating: 4 Stars

I received a copy of Kicking and Screaming from Negalley in exchange for an honest review.  Thank you!

One of my close friends has been keeping up with this series loyally, going to the comic shop every few weeks to pick up the latest edition, so, even though I wasn't sure about it, I requested this on Netgalley and was approved (and now I've actually read ahead of him because he hadn't managed to keep up... so I feel the slightest bit bad....).  I was surprised by how much I enjoyed it!

Kicking and Screaming follows Dinah (aka the Black Canary) after she has joined a band that's starting to get big.  She isn't really fit for the stage, being a superhero and all, but that doesn't really stop her from trying her hardest.  One of her band members, Ditto, it turns out, though, isn't really from this world, and some strange aliens, and Amanda Waller, and an ex-bandmate, are after her, so of course Dinah does all she can to protect this strange but charming kid.

I'm actually familiar with both the author and the artist.  Brenden Fletcher has been writing the most recent incarnation of Batgirl comics (of which I am a large fan) and, since Dinah features somewhat heavily in many issues of that, he has been writing this as well.  I liked returning to his writing, which still seems fresh even though I felt like it was somewhat of a strange direction to go with the character.  Annie Wu actually stepped in and was the artist for several issues of Hawkeye, which I'm another huge fan of.  While I wasn't the biggest fan of her when she was stepping in for Aja, I do love what she has done with this style for a Black Canary story line.  At first I wasn't sold, but after about one issue I was comfortable with it and found myself missing it the two issues she wasn't doing the art for.

My favorite part of the whole piece, though, was the self-contained story.  It wasn't super outlandish, made sense for the character, and still left enough loose ends to keep me wanting more.  Plus, the fact that there is only one major story going on, and it doesn't get sidetracked or just nudged at, had me very pleased.  I wasn't expecting such a well-rounded story (even though, under different, non-comic book circumstances I would call the ending a cop-out) and was more than happy to receive one.

Overall, if you're considering this one, I'd say pick it up.  It may not be what you're expecting, but it's very good in its own way.


Friday, March 11, 2016

ARC Graphic Novel Review: Paper Tigers (Hinges, Vol. 2)


Author: Meredith McClaren
Edition: eGalley courtesy of Netgalley
Related Reviews: Hinges Vol. 1
Release Date: February 3rd, 2016
Rating: 4 Stars

I received a copy of this from Netgalley for free in exchange for an honest review.  Thank you!

I rather enjoyed the first volume when I read it last year and immediately picked it up from Netgalley when I saw it was there!  It was a quick read and picked up pretty much where volume one left off.

The art is still absolutely adorable!  I love how charming and simple it is without being minimalist.  The story is moving forward at a good pace now, too.  Plus, a new character is introduced and I adore him!

Basically, read this series.  Oh, yeah, it's got a major cliffhanger...


Thursday, January 14, 2016

Graphic Novel Review: Skywalker Strikes (Star Wars, Vol. 1)

Writer: Jason Aaron
Artists: John Cassaday and Laura Martin
Edition: Paperback
Rating: 4 Stars

I picked this up pretty much the day after seeing The Force Awakens because I was in such a mood for Star Wars things.  And this did not disappoint.  If you even sorta considered picking it up, just do it!

Skywalker Strikes takes place between A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back, following Luke, Leia, and Han on a mission for the Rebellion.  Things don't turn out quite the way everyone would have liked, which leads Luke to reevaluate his status as a Jedi, and Han to confront what he's actually doing helping the Rebels.

Immediately it was like I could hear the voices coming off the page.  The art is fantastic at making the characters appear as they did in the movies, and the writing is so lively and exact that it's not hard to imagine everyone saying what they say.  It was a pleasure to fall back into this story without a hesitation, and it fleshes out the characters in such a nice way that even hard core movie fans can appreciate it.

Nothing was particularly surprising about the story, since the major spoiler at the end was spoiled for me months ago, when it originally happened.  In fact, you've probably heard of the spoiler, too, but I won't mention it here.  It actually helped me appreciate the character and heightened the tension knowing the truth.

Besides our heroes, Vader and Boba Fett play important roles in this volume.  I loved how ruthless Vader was portrayed, and it makes me eager to pick up his own series soon.  He's a bad guy, and while I've always kinda appreciated him, I didn't actually love to hate him until reading this.

So, yes, this is a must read if you're a fan of Star Wars.  And, with volume two coming out in a few weeks, you won't have to wait long to see where the story goes.

Thursday, December 24, 2015

5 Star Graphic Novel Review: Rio Bravo (Hawkeye Vol 4)

Writer: Matt Fraction
Artist: David Aja
Edition: Paperback
Rating: 5 Stars

Related Reviews: Little Hits | Hawkeye v Deadpool | LA Woman

Hawkeye is one of the best graphic novels you will ever read.  Not only is the art gorgeous and the story compelling, but the issues are unique and experimental, including, in this volume, one told via sign-language.  Somehow, Fraction and Aja have gotten it to work, and I'm so sad to be saying goodbye to this phenomenal run.

To avoid spoilers I'm keeping this review short.  Here's what you most need to know:

This volume is the most serious of all of them.  It takes the story up a notch and onto a level it hadn't touched before.  It also managed to wrap up the current storyline, and, borrowing from Kate's adventures in LA, sets up the next one.

Clint's relationship with his brother and the women in his life is expanded upon, and our hero finally realizes what it means to really lean on someone, and he finally accepts it, though he still has a lot of work to do in that department.  He also discovers what it means to be a hero- at least for him- and rises to the title.  There are also flashback scenes that give an in-depth view of his family and history.

Since Kate's a bit busy for the majority of this story, she's not around very much.  While I did miss her presence, new characters filled the gap nicely.

Overall, this was an amazing end to an amazing series.  I can't wait to see where the character goes and plan to pick up volume five sometime in the near future.

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

Graphic Novel Review: The Long Halloween

Author| Jeph Loeb  Artist| Tim Sale  Rating| 3 Stars
Edition| Kindle eBook

So, sadly, I still haven't found a Batman story that I like very much.  Sign me up for practically any other member of the Bat-family and I'm sold, but Bruce just doesn't keep me entertained.

Monday, November 9, 2015

New To You Book Club November: Cosmic Avengers Review

Author| Brian Michael Bendis  Artists| Steve McNiven and Sara Pichelli  Rating| 3.5 Stars
Edition| Paperback

Cosmic Avengers is the November book club pick of the month.  If you're curious about the club, click the tab at the top of the page for more information.  You still have the rest of the month to read this book, and I'd love to talk to you about it.

Thursday, November 5, 2015

Graphic Novel Review: Daredevil- Born Again

Author| Frank Miller  Artist| David Mazzucchelli  Rating| 4.5 Stars
Edition| Kindle eBook

For those of you who have been around the blog any time in the past year have probably noticed that I absolutely adore Daredevil.  I've reviewed quite a few Daredevil graphic novels this year, and while some of them aren't that great, others are fantastic.  This aligns with the latter and is probably the second best that I've read.

Monday, November 2, 2015

Graphic Novel Review: Hawkeye vs Deadpool

Author| Gerry Duggan  Artist| Matteo Lolli and Jacopo Camagni  Rating| 4 Stars
Edition| Paperback

This was a really fun read.  It lacked seriousness, but that's not too surprising seeing who was headlining the title.  If you're a fan of either Hawkeye or Deadpool, you'll enjoy this one.

Thursday, October 29, 2015

Graphic Novel Review: Priceless (Angela: Asgard's Assassin, Vol. 1)

Authors| Kieron Gillen and Marguerite Bennet  Artists| Phil Jimenez and Stephanie Hans
Rating| 4.5 Stars  Edition| Paperback

I was eager to see Angela's first headlining series before I even knew whether I'd like the character of the premise- it did not disappoint.

Thursday, October 22, 2015

Graphic Novel Review: Saga (Vol. 2)

Author| Brian K Vaughan  Artist| Fiona Staples  Rating| 4.5 Stars
Edition| Paperback
Related Reviews| Vol. 1
Buy Links| Amazon*/Barnes and Noble/Book Depository

This books picks up right where the last one left off.

Friday, October 16, 2015

Graphic Novel Review: Saga (Vol. 1)

Author| Brian K Vaughan  Artist| Fiona Staples  Rating| 4.5 Stars
Edition| Paperback

This series is super popular on Booktube and I can see why.

Monday, October 12, 2015

New To You Book Club October: East of West Review

Author| Jonathan Hickman  Artist| Nick Dragotta  Rating| 4.75 Stars
Edition| Paperback  

East of West is the bookclub pick of the month for my New To You Graphic Novel Book Club.  If you're interested in joining, you have all month to read it and I'm super excited to talk to you guys about it.  You can find info in the tab at the top of the page.

Thursday, October 1, 2015

5 Star Graphic Novel Review: Who Holds the Hammer? (Thor, Vol. 2)

Author| Jason Aaron  Artist| Russell Dauterman  Rating| 5 Stars
Edition| Hardcover
Related Reviews| Goddess of Thunder

As everyone knows, I absolutely love this series, so the following review is more of me just saying that and not giving anything away because you really want to be surprised by this one.